Unreasonable compensation at the end of the franchise agreement – dated September 17, 2019 – mr. AW Dolphin
This is stipulated in some franchise agreements the franchisee always owes the franchisor at least a certain amount of costs upon termination of the franchise agreement. On 20 August 2019, the Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal ruled, ECLI:NL:GHARL:2019:6745, that in the event that such costs are unreasonably onerous. The the departing franchisee therefore did not have to pay it.
The franchise agreement required the franchisee to always pay a minimum of € 5,400 in back-office costs upon termination of the franchise agreement. Franchisee has the annulment of this provision is invoked because it is considered general terms and conditions be considered and it would be unreasonably onerous (see Article 6:233, preamble and under a BW). The franchisee had argued that it back-office system was not functioning and that the height of the relevant costs are disproportionate to the actual costs. The franchisor had not contradicted this. That is why the court assumes that these costs for the franchisee upon termination of the franchise agreement is indeed unreasonably onerous, so the stipulation rightly nullified and the amount is not due on that ground.
It is not inconceivable that, if the franchisor had objected substantively to the unreasonable objection, the Court of Appeal would also have come to the same conclusion.
mr. AW Dolphijn – franchise lawyer
Ludwig & Van Dam Franchise attorneys, franchise legal advice. Do you want to respond?
Go to dolphijn@ludwigvandam.nl
Other messages
Bart’s Retail ruled in favor of subdistrict court judge in Nijmegen – 11 March 2016 – mr. T. Meijer
Bart's Retail ruled in favor of subdistrict court judge in Nijmegen
Interview Mr. J. Sterk in Distrifood – “Cheers about Dutch Franchise Code premature” – February 27, 2016
Interview Mr. J. Sterk in Distrifood - "Cheers about Dutch Franchise Code premature"
Newsletter Definitive Dutch Franchise Code – 24 February 2016 – DLvan Dam
Newsletter final Dutch Franchise Code – DLvan Dam
Minister Kamp explores legal anchoring Franchise Code – 17 February 2016
Minister Kamp is exploring the legal anchoring of the Franchise Code
Interview Mr. DL van Dam at BNR Nieuwsradio about the Dutch Franchise Code – February 17, 2016
Interview Mr. DL van Dam at BNR Nieuwsradio about the Dutch Franchise Code
Webshops in franchise relationships – February 12, 2016 – mr. J. van de Peppel
Webshops in franchise relationships