The franchise pre-agreement; the pre-contractual phase
It regularly happens that franchisor and franchisee conclude a pre-franchise agreement before actually entering into a franchise agreement. Such a pre-franchise agreement has many forms, which do not always do justice to its intention.
It may be useful to conclude a preliminary agreement on secrecy now and then and it may be stipulated to exchange information back and forth. Such a pre-agreement may also contain provisions on the division of the costs to be incurred by each other in the run-up to an actual franchise agreement.
The European Code of Honor Franchising 2006 regulates in article 3.4. which requirements such a pre-agreement should at least meet. The code is only directly applicable to members of the Dutch Franchise Association and franchisors who have indicated that they will apply it voluntarily. In addition to the aforementioned aspects, the franchisor must also provide the franchisee with information in advance about the purpose, scope and duration of the pre-agreement. The aim should preferably be limited to a regulation concerning the pre-contractual phase.
However, such a pre-agreement is increasingly being concluded to bind the parties to actually enter into a franchise agreement. If this is the case, the pre-agreement defeats its purpose.
After all, the pre-agreement should only provide an arrangement for the pre-contractual phase, comparable to any serious business negotiation process. If the preliminary agreement already obliges the parties to conclude a mutual franchise agreement, then in fact a franchise agreement has already been concluded, without the conditions under which this takes place usually being fully known in advance. This then often turns out to be a source of mutual claims, aimed at compensation and even compliance, if one of the parties still wishes to renounce an actual franchise relationship. In principle, it cannot be the case that implementation acts are already carried out on the basis of a pre-agreement and/or substantial investments are required from one of the parties. Under certain circumstances, it may also result in an attributable shortcoming if the pre-agreement keeps one of the parties on the line for a long time, without there being any real prospect of a franchise relationship.
The advice to franchisees is therefore also to properly assess the possible consequences of an offered pre-agreement. The advice to franchisors is to preferably limit a pre-agreement to a good and balanced arrangement in case of broken negotiations.
Ludwig & Van Dam franchise attorneys, franchise legal advice
Other messages
The manager (employee) who becomes a franchisee – fictitious employment?
On 14 December 2016, the subdistrict court judge of the District Court of Noord-Holland, ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2016:11031 (Employee/Espresso Lounge), considered the situation in which an employee
The Supreme Court sets strict requirements for franchise forecasts
A ruling by the Supreme Court on Friday casts a new light on the provision of profit and turnover forecasts to aspiring franchisees.
Infringement of exclusive service area by franchisor in connection with formula change dated February 27, 2017
On 30 January 2017, the provisional relief judge of the District Court of Noord-Holland, ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2017:688 (Intertoys/franchisee), was asked how to deal with the
Forecasts at startup franchise formula
The Amsterdam Court of Appeal ruled on 14 February 2017, ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2017:455 (Tot Straks/franchisee) on the question whether the franchisor had provided an unsatisfactory prognosis and whether the
Mandatory transfer of franchise business to franchisor?
On January 23, 2017, the District Court of Amsterdam, ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2017:412 (CoffeeCompany/Dam Spirit BV) rendered a judgment on the question whether a franchisee upon termination of the cooperation
Transfer customer data to franchisor
In its judgment of 10 January 2017, ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2017:68 (OnlineAccountants.nl), the Amsterdam Court ruled, among other things, on the question of how customer data should be transferred.