The franchise formula as the destination of the rented property
The Amsterdam Court of Appeal recently ruled on the question of whether a rental agreement can be dissolved and the rented property should be vacated, because the renting franchisee acted contrary to the destination clause in the rental agreement. That clause prescribed use of the leased property according to the franchise formula. See: http://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/inziendocument?id=ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2013:4913&keyword=franchise
The tenant, who is also the franchisee, defended himself against the claims, arguing, among other things, that the formula in practice deviated strongly from what had been agreed in writing at the time.
The Court of Appeal has established that a franchise formula is usually subject to development, and that this is all the more true in this case since the lessee is the formula’s first and only franchisee. The franchise agreement also stipulates that the franchisee is obliged to cooperate in the further development of the formula. The Court of Appeal ruled that it can be argued against the franchisee that he violated the destination clause in the rental agreement because he did not meet the essential characteristics of the formula.
It follows from this ruling that franchisees should be vigilant when interpreting the franchise formula, especially if the formula is relatively new and under development. Franchisors would do well to include a clause in the rental agreement that the tenant is obliged to use the formula, as well as that the tenant is obliged to cooperate in the further development of the formula.
Mr AW Dolphin – Franchise attorney
Ludwig & Van Dam Franchise attorneys,franchise legal advice. Do you want to respond? Mail to dolphijn@ludwigvandam.nl
Other messages
Director’s liability at franchisor?
Director's liability at franchisor?
Interim termination (franchise) agreement
On 3 February last, the 's-Hertogenbosch Court of Appeal ruled in a case that may also be relevant for franchise practice.
Disclosure obligation versus obligation to investigate when purchasing a franchise company, Who bears the risk?
Disclosure obligation versus obligation to investigate when purchasing a franchise company, Who bears the risk?
Termination of a Franchise Agreement
Franchise agreements are usually concluded for a specific period of time.
Gathering evidence in franchising relationships
Gathering factual evidence is sometimes one of the biggest challenges in litigation between a franchisee and a franchisor.
Is a personal guarantee or joint and several valid?
Is a personal guarantee or joint and several valid?