Qualitaria franchisee put in his shirt – dated July 2, 2020 – mr. JAJ Devilee
Introduction
The District Court of Zeeland-West-Brabant has rendered a judgment in legal proceedings initiated by a Qualitaria franchisee. In this case, the franchisee argued that the sales brochure, quick scan and market research (“recruitment documents”) made available to him – in which turnover forecasts are stated – are not good and that he has erred due to these faults. The franchisee allegedly entered into the franchise adventure with Kwalitaria on the basis of incorrect information, according to the franchisee. The court did not agree with the franchisee’s story. In fact, the court ordered the Qualitaria franchisee to pay compensation of approximately € 95,000, among other things. What happened?
Background
The Kwalitaria franchisee had conceived the plan to establish a combined branch of Kwalitaria and Delifrance in Baarle-Nassau. Based on this, the franchisor has made various recruitment documents available, which show that an excellent turnover can be achieved generated with such a branch at this location. In the end, this franchisee only opened a Kwalitaria branch and the turnover apparently lagged behind what the franchisor (and the consultancy it engaged) had forecast. The franchisee did not stop there and nullified the franchise agreement (and the associated purchase and rental agreement).
Subsequently, the Kwalitaria franchisee initiated legal proceedings against the franchisor. The court had to consider, among other things, whether the franchisee legally annulled the franchise agreement and the related agreements. If that were the case, the franchisee might be entitled to the fees already paid by him to the franchisor.
Judgment court
Despite the fact that the franchisee has argued, among other things, that (i) the franchisor knew that 50% of the market potential does not visit Kwalitaria stores, (ii) that the recruitment documents do not state that there is a bankrupt predecessor at this location, (iii) this location has suffered from long-term vacancy, (iv) the recruitment documents do not take into account a major competitor, (v) the location of the location has to do with a negative purchasing flow, (vi) the recruitment documents refer to an overestimated purchasing power tie and incorrectly do not take into account the outflow of purchasing power to surrounding municipalities, this cannot offer this Qualitaria franchisee any solace in these proceedings.
The court simply concludes that the franchisee has not sufficiently substantiated, or at least that it has not been established, that there are inaccuracies in the recruitment documents. For this reason, the Kwalitaria franchisee was not allowed to nullify the franchise agreement, so that the annulment of the franchise agreement was not legally valid. The result is that the franchisor rightly argued that the franchisee was not allowed to annul the franchise agreement and that the damage suffered by the franchisor as a result must be compensated by the Qualitaria franchisee.
Conclusion
Insofar as you intend to terminate your franchise agreement, never take a decision to terminate it too lightly, also to prevent you from getting the lid on the nose at a later stage. First seek legal advice on this in order to examine the possibilities.
mr. JAJ Devilee
Ludwig & Van Dam Franchise attorneys, franchise legal advice.
Do you want to respond? Go to devilee@ludwigvandam.nl
Other messages
Termination of lease agreement after purchase of retail space
At the end of 2010, the Supreme Court ruled on the waiting period that applies to termination due to urgent personal use.
Forecast: developments franchisees
The court in Arnhem has recently again ruled on so-called 'prognosis problems'.
Webshops by the franchisor: like it or not?
Today, more and more franchisors are realizing that, in addition to the distribution channel that the franchisees form
Failing to cooperate in checking hygiene requirements of the franchisee
The court in Amsterdam recently ruled in a case where a franchisee did not meet all hygiene requirements.
‘If the employee starts franchising…’. The employer’s duty of care as a franchisor
It will not be easy to assume that a 'normal' employee has given up his employment contract. However, what...
Sale of rental rights supermarket location not allowed
Recently, the Court of Appeal in The Hague has ruled that supermarket organizations have to switch locations for the penny.