Partial indebtedness of entrance fees due to lack of turnover and non-delivery of contractual performance by the franchisor
Court of Rotterdam
The franchisee rightly invokes unforeseen circumstances due to the lack of turnover and successfully claims moderation of the entrance fee due. The fact that no turnover has been realized within the framework of the franchise agreement, which moreover allows settlement of the entrance fee in connection with future turnover, is, in the opinion of the court, a circumstance that entails that the franchisee rightly invokes (partial) ) innocence. In addition, the franchisor has not provided any significant services. In addition to offering the franchise formula, only general printed matter, business cards, billboards and a general introduction were provided. Thus, the obligation of advice and assistance in accordance with the franchisor’s duty of care has apparently not been complied with. The court eventually halves the contractually due entrance fee.
NB: The fact that the court recognizes the lack of turnover as an unforeseen circumstance may also mean a new entry in the event of unrealized forecasts by franchisees. The ruling once again emphasizes the far-reaching duty of care of franchisors with regard to the actual ability to achieve reasonably expected turnovers, whether or not laid down in financial forecasts. If this core obligation from the franchise relationship is not met, the franchisee can invoke various grounds in relation to an action for damages against the franchisor.
Mr Th.R. Ludwig – Franchise lawyer
Ludwig & Van Dam Franchise attorneys, franchise legal advice Would you like to respond? Mail to ludwig@ludwigvandam.nl
Other messages
Bart’s Retail ruled in favor of subdistrict court judge in Nijmegen – 11 March 2016 – mr. T. Meijer
Bart's Retail ruled in favor of subdistrict court judge in Nijmegen
Interview Mr. J. Sterk in Distrifood – “Cheers about Dutch Franchise Code premature” – February 27, 2016
Interview Mr. J. Sterk in Distrifood - "Cheers about Dutch Franchise Code premature"
Newsletter Definitive Dutch Franchise Code – 24 February 2016 – DLvan Dam
Newsletter final Dutch Franchise Code – DLvan Dam
Minister Kamp explores legal anchoring Franchise Code – 17 February 2016
Minister Kamp is exploring the legal anchoring of the Franchise Code
Interview Mr. DL van Dam at BNR Nieuwsradio about the Dutch Franchise Code – February 17, 2016
Interview Mr. DL van Dam at BNR Nieuwsradio about the Dutch Franchise Code
Webshops in franchise relationships – February 12, 2016 – mr. J. van de Peppel
Webshops in franchise relationships