How far does the non-competition clause extend?
The Supreme Court recently issued a judgment regarding a non-competition clause in a franchise relationship.
From a specifically established private company, X supplies automation work to the competitor of the former franchisor. The franchisor has previously purchased X’s business. The question arises to what extent X has violated the non-competition clause in the purchase agreement by selling to the competition. Strictly speaking, the automation activities do not fall under the core activity of the ordered and intended under the non-competition clause. However, the franchisor shows that the activities have been used as a cover, since X is closely involved in the creation of a formula that competes with him. The activities turn out to be specifically aimed at the competitor’s store concept and, moreover, are not supplied to other customers.
Both the District Court and the Court of Appeal come to the conclusion that there is indeed a cover-up and that the non-competition clause should therefore be honoured. X is sentenced to pay very high fines, rising to more than € 800,000 on appeal.
The Supreme Court rules that the Court of Appeal has not ruled on correct grounds and refers the case to another Court to reassess the whole. However, the case shows that constructions used to circumvent the non-compete clause are extremely risky.
A franchisee who has doubts about the interpretation of the non-compete clause would be wise to carefully and carefully consider whether or not the new activities fall under this clause. Coordination with the former franchisor can prevent many problems in this regard. If this does not yield results, a very careful consideration in another way is necessary.
Mr Th.R. Ludwig – Franchise lawyer
Ludwig & Van Dam Franchise attorneys, franchise legal advice Would you like to respond? Mail to ludwig@ludwigvandam.nl
![](https://ludwigvandam.megaconcept.nl/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/232court-min-400x222.jpg)
Other messages
Agency: some outlines
In practice, questions are asked with some regularity regarding the legal nature
Rental price change
Following on from earlier published articles of my hand, I will once again deal with a tenancy law issue below.
Franchise Fees
An extremely important subject for both the franchisee and the franchisor that is invariably included in the franchise agreement concerns the franchise fees, often referred to as the term
Insured and well
Occasionally, a franchise agreement contains a clause that obliges the franchisee to take out legal expenses insurance.
Rayon protection II: limitation of the exclusive area.
As a follow-up to the contribution in the previous Newsletter, this time the (possibilities of) curtailment of the exclusive franchise area will be discussed. In most franchise agreements
Franchise Agreements and Terms and Conditions
Franchise agreements often include concise arrangements with regard to delivery and payment conditions.