Extension under “the then applicable conditions”
Many franchise agreements contain a franchise renewal clause that allows the franchisee to re-exercise the franchise for another five years, provided that the franchise agreement is accepted “on the terms then in force”.
Does this somewhat cryptic formulation constitute a license for a franchisor to unilaterally change the conditions, i.e. the content of the new franchise agreement, when the contract extension is up for discussion? By no means. It has been established in case law that a franchisor is certainly not free to freely change the conditions in the new franchise agreement in accordance with its own insight and policy in the event of a contract renewal. For example, if a higher fee is suddenly requested, this means that the option granted can in practice only be invoked under such additional conditions that this is more than the franchisee could expect. The conduct of the franchisor in question described here may then be unlawful.
Does this mean that a franchisor cannot change his franchise agreement at all in the event of a contract renewal if the above option is included in the franchise agreement? Not that either. The franchisor can indeed change and add to various subjects in the franchise agreement. However, it is important to reach consensus in advance with the existing franchisees, for example in consultation with the franchise council. In this way, surprises in the event of a contract extension for existing franchisees are eliminated in advance and a clear situation is created long before any contract extension that benefits everyone.
Ludwig & Van Dam franchise attorneys, franchise legal advice
Other messages
Franchising is on the rise: ‘There is still a huge amount of room for it in the Netherlands’
An interview with mr. AW Dolphijn about franchise. De Beren, ...
The franchise agreement without (heavy demands on) know-how
In the 2023-1 edition of Contracting magazine, I published a ...
Standstill period violation
On 15 March 2023, the District Court of Noord-Holland, ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2023:2636, ...
Violation post prohibition of competition, no fine!
The District Court of Zeeland-West-Brabant ruled on 15 March 2023, ...
Termination of the franchise agreement due to the introduction of the Franchise Act
On 28 February 2023, the Court of Appeal of 's-Hertogenbosch, ...
The penalty clause in the franchise agreement
They appear in almost every franchise agreement: penalty clauses. ...