Excusable infringement of territory exclusivity
The District Court of Rotterdam recently ruled on a matter concerning infringement of the agreed district exclusivity. The franchise agreement stipulated that the franchisee enjoyed the exclusive right to operate the formula within a radius of 15 kilometers from its location. In fact, however, several branches of the franchisor were located within a radius of 15 kilometers. Franchisee claimed to suffer damage as a result of this infringement. The franchisee requested an injunction in interlocutory proceedings subject to forfeiture of a penalty. The court rules that the alleged damage by the franchisee has not been substantiated or has not been sufficiently substantiated and that there is therefore no urgent interest in instituting such a claim in summary proceedings. The court also considers that the exclusivity was in fact not complied with and the franchisee was also aware of this. Moreover, the franchisee had failed to protest in time. The franchisee’s claims were rejected in full.
The foregoing means that franchisees cannot lightly invoke provisions in the franchise agreement without a well-founded interest if the parties actually act differently over a long period of time. In those cases, the exceeding of the standard may be excusable. For franchisors, it is therefore easier to enforce standards that are exceeded if the provisions are observed more strictly in practice and if the policy to this effect is clear. In particular, franchisees must protest in good time.
mr J. Sterk – franchise lawyer
Ludwig & Van Dam Franchise attorneys, franchise legal advice Would you like to respond? Mail to info@ludwigvandam.nl
![](https://ludwigvandam.megaconcept.nl/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/232court-min-400x222.jpg)
Other messages
mr. Th.R. Ludwig gives a course for franchisees at the NFV
mr. Th.R. Ludwig gives a course for franchisees at the NFV
Interests Association of Franchisees of the Netherlands (BVFN) in conversation with the Minister
Interests Association of Franchisees of the Netherlands (BVFN) in conversation with the Minister
Termination of the franchise formula and end of subletting
Can the franchisor - without being liable for damages - discontinue the franchise formula and also terminate the rental relationship with the franchisee, whereby the franchisor continues with a web shop?
Converted C-1000 entrepreneurs to AH not profitable
Various ex-C1000 entrepreneurs who are now active under the AH flag are considering selling their supermarket.
New AH’ers are thinking about sales
New AH'ers are thinking about sales
New AH ers are thinking about sales supervised by mr. J. Strong
New AH ers are thinking about sales supervised by mr. J. Strong