Despite the franchisee’s counterclaim, the franchisor justified dissolution of the franchise contract
Court of Rotterdam
The Rotterdam court recently ruled that payment arrears of more than € 80,000 is sufficient for the franchisor to dissolve the franchise agreement.
The overdue payment is sufficient to terminate the franchise agreement, despite the fact that the franchisee claims that the franchisor has not made any marketing efforts or provided marketing materials, even though the franchisee has paid € 400,000 for this. However, according to the court, the alleged counterclaim is not substantiated at all. Furthermore, it has not become apparent that the franchisee has given the franchisor notice of default at any time, so that there can be no question of default on the part of the franchisor and therefore no due and payable counterclaim has arisen. Suspension of payment arrears of more than € 80,000 is therefore not justified.
The Rotterdam court therefore ruled that the franchisor was right to dissolve the franchise agreement and furthermore decreed that the franchisee may no longer act as a franchisee to the outside world. Furthermore, the claim of more than € 80,000 to be paid.
For suspension by the franchisee in such a situation it is necessary that there is a well-founded substantiation, including notice of default, and not that the unsubstantiated allegation is raised in court for the first time.
Mr Th.R. Ludwig – Franchise lawyer
Ludwig & Van Dam Franchise attorneys, franchise legal advice Would you like to respond? Mail to ludwig@ludwigvandam.nl
Other messages
Tax aspects of franchising – for franchisors and franchisees
In practice, we see that attention to taxation within franchise ...
No accountability, no fee?
A ruling from the Midden-Nederland court of October 18, 2023 ...
Accountability for franchise, marketing and IT fees
A ruling from the Midden-Nederland court of October 18, 2023 ...
ROZ model contracts (rental) adjusted: what are the consequences for Franchise relationships?
On April 10, 2024, the Real Estate Council (ROZ) announced ...
Abuse of power in the French supermarket sector
After Belgium, France has now also had enough when it ...
Supermarket location due to exceeding the decision period by the municipality
In a dispute with the municipality of Helmond, the issue ...