Article Franchise+ – “Franchisor uses “derivative formula” (without his knowledge)” – mr. AW Dolphijn – dated September 9, 2020
Many franchisors will not be aware of the fact that they use a “derived formula” as referred to in the Franchise Act. However, such a “derived formula” can soon be found. If that is the case, various legal rights and obligations must be taken into account.
A derivative formula, as referred to under the Franchise Act, is a formula that, in the perception of the public, shows many similarities with the franchise formula and therefore evokes strong associations with that franchise formula. In such a case, the public will think that it concerns the same formula, while in practice there are two separate formulas, both of which are used by or on behalf of the relevant franchisor.
The derived formula can be a franchise formula in its own right, but that is not necessarily the case. This could be a webshop with the same brand name and wholly or partly the same house style, on which (largely) the same products are sold as in the franchise establishment). Another example is the situation in which the franchisor of a supermarket chain intends to set up a formula in the form of, for example, a chain of station shops, where more or less the same products are for sale as in the franchise establishment. Separate home delivery activities may also fall under a derived formula.
Formulas that are set up by a franchisor in addition to an existing franchise formula managed by the same franchisor, but which have their own trade name, house style, etc., as a result of which the public does not associate that formula with that existing franchise formula, are not counted as derivative formulas. The possible circumstance that the two formulas concern more or less the same services or products, or are aimed at the same relevant market, does not change this.
The franchisor who decides to use a derived formula (whether or not by the franchisor itself or via third parties) must notify the franchisees of this in a timely manner. In doing so, the franchisor must explain the content and purport of the derivative formula in question.
Subsequently, under certain circumstances, the franchisor must obtain the consent of the franchisee for the introduction of the derivative formula. If the use of the derivative formula may have financial consequences for the franchisee and that impact exceeds any agreed threshold amount, the franchisor will require prior approval.
Acting contrary to the rules of the Franchise Act can quickly result in an unlawful act. Franchisors are therefore well advised to always consider whether there is a legal concept of the “derived formula” when changing their activities.
mr. AW Dolphin – franchise lawyer
Ludwig & Van Dam Franchise attorneys, franchise legal advice. Do you want to respond?
Go to dolphijn@ludwigvandam.nl
Other messages
Alex Dolphijn in the Financial Dagblad about the judgment of the Supreme Court regarding Street-One
Franchisors more liable for incorrect forecasts Franchisees can now more easily hold their parent organization liable for incorrect profit and turnover forecasts.
Supermarket letter – 17
Supreme Court: More quickly liable for forecasts
Article in Entrance: “Small print”
“When I do business with a supplier, I never read the fine print. Recently I noticed that there are all kinds of things in it that I actually do not agree with.
Column Franchise+ – mr. Th.R. Ludwig: “Delivery stop by franchisor again not allowed”
Once again, the president in preliminary relief proceedings ruled on the question whether a franchisor's supply stop against the franchisee was permitted, with the franchisee paying a substantial
The manager (employee) who becomes a franchisee – fictitious employment?
On 14 December 2016, the subdistrict court judge of the District Court of Noord-Holland, ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2016:11031 (Employee/Espresso Lounge), considered the situation in which an employee
The Supreme Court sets strict requirements for franchise forecasts
A ruling by the Supreme Court on Friday casts a new light on the provision of profit and turnover forecasts to aspiring franchisees.